Violenza contro le persone LGBTI in Italia: ILGA Europe scrive a Monti, ai presidenti di Camera e Senato e all'OSCAD

To the President of the Council of Ministers of Italy, Pr. Mario MONTI

To the President of the Italian House of Representatives, On. Gianfranco FINI

To the President of the Italian Senate, On. Renato SCHIFANI

To the President of the Observatory for security against discriminatory acts (OSCAD),
Mr Francesco Cirillo

Violence against lesbian, gay, bisexual trans and intersex (LGBTI) people

In the last years, the number of homophobic and transphobic incidents reported in Italy
has been growing to reach an alarming level. ILGA-Europe, the European Region of the
International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association believes that this
phenomenon provides full evidence of an unacceptable context of violence against
lesbian, gay, bisexual and trans people.

In the last days, various dramatic incidents were documented around the Roma Pride
2012. This culminated in a violent aggression against one of the organisers of the event,
Guido Allegrezza, who was severely beaten up by five young men on 13 June. These
attacks are the last examples of a more general situation that has been documented by
our member organisations in Italy, including Arcigay, Arcilesbica and Certi Diritti. A
report by Arcigay, with the cases of violence and homophobia and transphobia reported
in the press in 2011, is attached to this letter.

Wherever such violence happens, ILGA-Europe stresses the importance of a strong and
comprehensive reaction by all the relevant public authorities, in order to tackle
intolerance and prevalent forms of hate crime. All European governments, including the
Italian government, have subscribed to such principles, in political commitments such as
the OSCE’s Ministerial Council Decision N° 9/09 of December 20091, or the
Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of
Europe to member states on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual
orientation or gender identity2.

The recent events show how necessary it is for Italy to promptly and fully implement
such commitments. One key measure is the adoption of legislative measures on
appropriate criminal penalties for violence, threats of violence, incitement to violence and
related harassment based on sexual orientation or gender identity. In the Italian context,
it is time to amend the Mancini law of 25 June 1993, to enlarge its scope to hate crimes

perpetrated with a homophobic or a transphobic motivation. Currently, the law’s
provisions only address violence based on ethnicity, nationality and religion. ILGA-
Europe is aware that various bills were proposed in the last years, and that their
rejection by the Parliament sent a very negative message to the public.

In addition, OSCE and Council of Europe commitments go beyond the adoption of
appropriate criminal legislation. It is indeed equally important to make sure that the
perpetration of such violence is vigorously investigated, and that, where appropriate
evidence is found, those responsible are prosecuted, tried and duly punished. Data on
hate crime shall be collected, maintained and made public in a reliable way. To achieve
these objectives, it is essential to build confidence between police forces, prosecution
services and victims as well as the NGOs representing the potentially victimised
communities. The development of professional training and capacity building activities
for law-enforcement officers is an important action in that respect.

More generally, we would like to emphasize that the rights to be free from discrimination
and to be protected from violence, including violence motivated by hatred, are among
the rights recognised by a number of international and European human rights
instruments, legally binding for the States. Homophobia and/or transphobia may already
be seen as aggravating factors in criminal behaviour in 16 member states of the
European Union.

The European Court of Human Rights has started developing case law in that respect.
Its decisions Nachova and others v. Bulgaria (2005), Secic v. Croatia (2007) and
Milanovic v. Serbia (2010) made clear that States have an obligation to investigate on
the racist or religious motivation of a crime. More recently, in the context of hate speech,
the Court stressed, that “discrimination based on sexual orientation was as serious as
discrimination based on race, origin or colour (Vejdeland and others v. Sweden, 2012).

On the basis of these legal and political context elements, ILGA-Europe believes that the
Italian Government and the Italian Parliament have a duty to give a remedy to a worrying
national situation, by seriously implementing the commitments they have made in
European fora.

We look forward to hearing from you on the initiatives that the Italian Government and
Parliament can form to improve the national standards on tackling homophobic and
transphobic violence.

Yours sincerely,

Gabi Calleja
Martin K.I. Christensen
Co-Chairs of the Executive Board

È la prima volta che passi di qua?

Siamo un’associazione che si occupa di libertà sessuali, fuori da ghetti e stereotipi. Non pensiamo di essere una minoranza semplicemente perché ci occupiamo delle libertà di tutti: anche delle tue. Se ti è piaciuto quello che hai letto, torna più spesso: abbiamo tante cose di cui ci occupiamo da raccontarti. Tutte queste cose le facciamo solo grazie a chi ci sostiene. Puoi farlo anche subito.

Dona ora

Vuoi dare una mano?

Iscriviti a Certi Diritti per un anno. Sono 50 euro spesi bene. Per la tua libertà e quella di tutte e tutti. Troppi? Puoi anche donare 5 euro al mese.


Chi te lo fa fare?

Di darci dei soldi per portare avanti quello che facciamo già adesso senza chiederti nulla? Nessuno: però se nessuno dona o si iscrive per sostenere i costi delle nostre attività, queste attività non si faranno. E saremo tutti un po’ meno liberi e con meno diritti.

Dona ora


Iniziative, appuntamenti…
Rimani in contatto!

Facebook Twitter Instagram Whatsapp